Islamic Occasions | Holy Ramadan | Hajj-e-Baytullah | Mazloom Hussain | Screensavers | Moral Stories | Islamic Quiz | Islam Page
Islamic Discussion Forum Moral Stories Islamic Greeting Cards

Welcome: Guest   
 All Forums
  Dialogue about Islam Occasions
    
Subject Textual Critism of Islam
Message by: Asiba Naibkhil on November 26 2009 at 2:05 PM  
Country: Canada   Joined: November 26 2009   Total Posts: 1 Search for other posts by Asiba Naibkhil

Asalam wa'alakium,

My name is Asiba and I have a problem that I'd like some help on. First thing first, my faith in Islam is unshakable and complete always has been, is and will be. Currently, I'm attending a Christian University to broaden my knowledge of other faiths as I increase my knowledge in my own faith as well. One of my New Testament professor has challanged me with a question. He told me that he knows his Bible has errors, yet they have old manuscripts to fall back on dating from very early. And I had replied to him that our Qur'an is errorless, it is the word of Allah (SWT) and my personal Qur'an at home is identical to the one that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) had memorized. Clearly that is impossible for a non-believer to believe because they believe in human error. He asked me how can a Muslim believe prove that the Qur'an is errorless if we keep destorying (placing old Qur'ans in clean lakes and rivers or burning them when too old to use) them, without using the faith card, without saying that is faith and is improvable. I would like to know if anyone has done enough research on Islam about older and oldest Quranic texts and manuscripts, like the ones in Egypt. or perhaps even a copy of Tawhiid, Zabur or Ingeel. that maybe a strech but it's worth researching.

thank you,

Jazakum'allah khayr.


Message by: farzana on November 01 2009 at 4:18 PM  
Country: Canada   Joined: November 01 2009   Total Posts: 2 Search for other posts by farzana
salaam
I think if people go and do research they will invent thing which doesn't exist .I have learnt just like you burn ,or clean lakes I now nearly 55 years old and I'm learn more from Quran ,hadith, and webside.Put your trust in Allah that you are doing a good thing.Allah Bless.

Message by: asad khan on November 20 2009 at 1:31 PM  
Country: Pakistan   Joined: November 20 2009   Total Posts: 2 Search for other posts by asad khan
THE CURRENT HOLY BIBLE IS CORRUPTED AND MANY VERSES AND SAYINGS AND CLAIMS HAVE BEEN INCLUDED BY HUMAN. SO WHAT IS BIBLE??? FROM WHERE IT HAS COME????? WE MUSLIM BELIEVE ONLY THE INJEEL THAT HAS BEEN REVELED ON JESUS(PBUH). WHERE IS THAT INJEEL???? AND WHAT IS BIBLE???? AND QURAN HAS THE COMPLETE AND COMPREHENSIVE SOLUTIONS OF ALL PROBLEMS OF ANY ERA AND ALSO PROVIDES THE COMPLETE SOLUTIONS FOR HUMANITY, PEACE AND HARMONY. PROFESSOR WILLIUM MOE( AN ARCH ENEMY OF ISLAM) EVEN THAT PERSON SAID ABOUT QURAN THAT"YES THE SPECIALITY AND MIRACLE OF ISLAM IS THAT THE HOLY BOOK QURAN IS STILL IN ITS GENIUN AND ORIGINAL FORM. NOT A SINGLE WORD HAS BEEN REPLACED OR CHANGED IN IT PROVED THROUGH LONG RESEARCH OF ISLAMIC ENCYCLOPEDIA"

Message by: safeedah on November 20 2009 at 7:32 PM  
Country: Mauritius   Joined: November 20 2009   Total Posts: 1 Search for other posts by safeedah
Salam,

I have seen myself oldest Quranic texts written by the khalifa (not printed)in sarja museum. Well, you can advise that person to have a look.

Our Holy Prophet (pbuh) memorized the holy Quran so do our hafiz till now. That man need to gather 4 hafiz in 4 corner of the world with different age and listen.

Alhamdullillah our scholars are still learning the signification of our holy quran so that understand prefectly but not searching for faults to modify!!

Post a Reply

Sorry, you must be a registered user to post a message on Islamic Discussion Forum
 
Islamic Discussion Forum: Islamic Occasions Network
Forum Jump: